Cult favorites you say? Yes, the makeup products that have a dedicated fan base, and nothing but great reviews for years and years. To come up with my list I googled ‘cult favorite makeup items’ and chose the products that were mentioned on every list, and a few that were quite popular recently. On this or that? I will choose a product out of the two that I would rather have in my makeup collection. I’ll just let you know that I didn’t do well following the rules LOL.
Let’s get it popping!
OPI’s Lincoln Park After Dark vs. OPI’s My Private Jet | I’m taking both. And yes, I understand the rules to this challenge! These nail polishes have been on my “buy that stuff!” list for a long time, and I still don’t have them. *takes notes*
Smashbox Photofinish Foundation Primer vs. Benefit the Porefessional Foundation Primer | I have tried both and I could seriously live without them. Can I swap out the photo finish primer for the primer water? I’ll take that all day!
MAC Ruby Woo vs. MAC Angel | I’ll go with Angel. I have my favorite red lip colors already and Ruby Woo has no place in my collection. It’s also very drying according to like everyone. Now if ‘Riri Woo’ ever happens to come back out I’ll take 10!
Laura Mercier Tranlucent Loose Setting Powder vs. Coty Airspun Loose Face Powder | I’m going with Coty today! Laura’s powder is highly respected but I am more interested in the Deep Dark version of her loose setting powder. Also, Coty is quite affordable and it’s been around for ages!
Feline Kohl Pencil by MAC vs. Perversion Eyeliner by Urban Decay | This may shock some people but I am not a big user of pencil liner or mascara. Due to my previously owning perversion and loving it, I’ll take that!
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Eyeliner vs. KVD Tattoo Liquid Eyeliner | I’m a little undecided… I mean they are both pen liners and very popular. Since Stila has been around longer I will go with that.
Diorshow Mascara in Problack Mascara vs. Maybelline Great Lash Mascara |
An oldie but goodie. I have built a good rapport with ms. Great Lash, so she won! I don’t care to use mascara often so if I do I am not balling out on it.
Urban Decay Eye-shadow Primer Potion vs. MAC Painterly Paint Pot | For no rhyme or reason, I’m going with Primer Potion on this one. They are both cool in my eyes.
Bobbi Brown Skin Foundation Stick vs. Hourglass Vanish Seamless Finish Foundation Stick | I feel like Bobbi Brown has solidified her spot as the best foundation stick on the market. Aside from that the hourglass colors seem too yellow for me to even use their f.s. I love the packaging though – it is quite clear who won this one. Bobbi!
I hope you enjoyed this random challenge I created! If you had to pick, what would you choose?